8oz.shredded mozzarella2 cups, divided (½ cup for topping)
12oz.shredded colby jack3 cups, divided (1 cup for topping)
½cupshredded parmesanfor topping
½cupreserved pasta water
Chopped chives or parsley for servingoptional
Instructions
Heat the oven to 350ºF and bring a large pot of salted water to a boil over high heat. Butter a 9” by 13” baking dish. Cook pasta according to package directions, reserve ½ cup pasta water, set aside, drain pasta, and add to the buttered baking dish.
While pasta cooks, to a food processor or blender, add cottage cheese, eggs, milk, garlic, paprika, mustard, salt, pepper, and nutmeg, puree or blend until combined. To the milk mixture, add the cheddar, 1 ½ cups of the mozzarella, and 2 cups of the colby jack, blend until combined, mixture will have a pancake batter consistency, with tiny grains of cheese.
Pour cheese mixture into the baking dish with the pasta, stir until completely combined, add in about ¼ cup of the reserved pasta water and stir. The mixture should look creamy and wet but not soupy. Top with remaining ½ cup mozzarella, 1 cup colby jack, and ½ cup parmesan (I mix the cheeses together in a bowl before sprinkling on top of the casserole).
Bake in the center of the oven for 25 minutes, until bubbly and beginning to brown around the edges slightly. Remove the casserole, position the rack to the upper portion of the oven, place the casserole back in the oven so that the top is 6 inches from the broiler and broil for about 4 minutes, until the cheese is very bubbly and medium golden brown. (keep an eye on it to avoid burning the cheese).
Allow mac and cheese to rest on a cooling rack for 5 minutes (any oil collected on top will get absorbed back into the casserole). Sprinkle with chopped chives or parsley just before serving.
Notes
Shred your own cheese! Pre-shredded cheese is convenient, but it’s coated with anti-caking agents that keep it from melting smoothly. I run all my cheese through the food processor, and it’s done in minutes. Many grocery store deli counters will also shred any block cheese you buy in the store. Just ask nicely, then finish your shopping while they shred. Or grab a box grater and call it an arm workout!MAKE AHEAD: For the best texture, freeze it unbaked. Cook the pasta 2 to 3 minutes shy of al dente, then make and assemble the mac and cheese. Reserve the topping cheeses until baking day. Cover unbaked mac and cheese tightly with plastic wrap, then a layer of foil, and freeze for up to 3 months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator. Remove all plastic wrap before baking, and bake as directed, adding 10 to 15 minutes since it’s going in cold.You can also freeze the baked mac and cheese, but the flavor fades a little and the texture can lose some creaminess. Let the baked casserole cool completely, then wrap and freeze it the same way.